Nature Notes From Crater Lake
Volume 23, 1992
Saving Bull Trout in Sun Creek
By Mark Buktenica
Bull trout (Salvelinus confluentus)
and dolly varden (Salvelinus malma) were once considered to be
the same species. They have been separated because of genetic,
morphological, and behavioral differences. In general, bull trout are
the "inland" form, while dolly varden migrate to the ocean (where they
spend much of their adult life) and return to reproduce in freshwater.
This makes the dolly varden an anadromous fish, similar in behavior to
salmon.
Once found in most major river systems
in the Pacific Northwest, bull trout distribution has been significantly
reduced over the past 30 years and many local extinctions have occurred.
Oregon's Klamath River Basin represents the southern Limit of present
day bull trout distribution. The Klamath populations are genetically
distinct from other populations in the region and are now restricted to
cold headwater streams. Habitat degradation and introduction of
non-native fish species are believed to be the primary causes for the
decline. Bull trout have been Listed as a Category 2 Species (candidate
species under the Endangered Species Act of 1973) by the U.S. Fish and
Wildlife Service (USFWS) and is listed as a sensitive species by the
State of Oregon.
Bull trout were probably the only fish
species present in Sun Creek, a high elevation, second order stream,
prior to early introductions of non-native salmonids. National Park
Service (NPS) and Oregon Department of Fish and Wildlife (ODFW) records
indicate repeated stocking of rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss)
and brook trout (Salvelinus fontinalis) in Sun Creek between 1928
and 1971. The only park-wide stream survey conducted during this period
took place in 1947. A seasonal naturalist named Orthello Wallis (who
later became the first aquatic biologist ever employed by the NPS) found
bull trout, rainbow trout, and brook trout in Sun Creek.
A resurvey of Sun Creek was made in the
summer of 1989 to investigate the distribution and abundance of fish
relative to habitat characteristics. The survey was funded as part of
Klamath River Basin water rights adjudication. Sun Creek was surveyed
from its headwaters to the park boundary. Bull trout, brook trout, and
hybrids from the two species were collected. No rainbow trout were
collected in the portion of Sun Creek within the park and may no longer
exist in the stream.
Investigators observed that habitat
utilization by bull trout and brook trout was very similar. Competition
and hybridization with brook trout have probably reduced the
distribution of bull trout in Sun Creek. Bull trout were restricted to a
1.9 km reach of the stream and the total number of adult bull trout was
estimated at 130 fish. Such a low population density is alarming, since
it suggests that local extinction could occur within the next few years.
The NPS is developing a bull trout
management program whose goals are to remove brook trout from Sun Creek,
build a barrier to prevent re-invasion, and to re-establish a
self-sustaining population of bull trout in Sun Creek within Crater Lake
National Park. During 1991, park staff convened a "Bull Trout Recovery
Team" to develop recommendations on how to best achieve these goals. It
consisted of representatives from the NPS, USFWS, ODFW, U.S. Forest
Service, California Department of Fish and Game, and Oregon State
University. A final report from the group is expected in early 1992 and
will form the basis for the first active fish management project ever
undertaken in the park. An environmental assessment will be available
for public comment before any management action is taken.
Visitors should note that fishing for
bull trout in Crater Lake National Park and throughout south central
Oregon is prohibited by state law. Bull trout within the park are also
protected by federal regulations. Fishing for other species in most park
streams is permitted. Copies of fishing regulations are available at the
park's visitor centers. Fishing in Crater Lake for kokanee salmon (Oncorhynchus
nerka) and rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss) is allowed. No
state license is required and fishing on the lake has been good in
recent years.