Nature Notes From Crater Lake
Volume 25, 1994
A Fish Tale You Can Believe
By Dave Fuller
During my summer seasons as a ranger, I
have answered many questions about America's deepest lake. "Are there
fish in the lake?" is one of the most frequently asked. The answer is
yes, but the explanation cannot end there. How the fish arrived in
Crater Lake is relevant because no streams breach the caldera wall.
In 1888, William Gladstone Steel -- who
was later known as the park's founder -- decided that people needed a
recreational diversion upon arrival at the Lake of Blue Waters. As if
the breathtaking beauty was not enough! So Steel decided to stock Crater
Lake.
Initially, fingerlings (rainbow trout)
were brought from the Rogue River to Crater Lake. Over a period of 40-50
years, five more species of fish were introduced: brook and brown trout,
steelhead, coho (silver) salmon, and kokonee salmon. I am no
ichthyologist, but it seems strange that Will and his associates placed
steelhead (a rainbow trout that spends part of its life cycle in the
ocean) and coho salmon in a lake with no inlets or outlets. Since both
of these species move from ocean to fresh water streams to spawn,
neither of them would survive very long in the closed system of Crater
Lake.
For that matter, there have been no
sightings of brook or brown trout since the 1960s. Among the six
introduced to the lake, the only survivors appear to be the rainbow
trout and kokonee salmon. Both are well equipped for Crater Lake's cold,
deep water.
Since the two existing species of fish
in the lake were put there for recreational purposes, I bet all you
anglers are wondering how the fishing is at Crater Lake. Writing as one
who has been on a four year quest to catch the "Crater Lake Monster," I
feel qualified to provide some insight. Whether or not you will tell
fishing stories about Crater Lake depends on what your expectations are
before you start to fish.
If you come to the seventh deepest lake
in the world and expect to fish the whole lake, you are badly mistaken.
Just one trail provides access to the lake's shoreline. The Cleetwood
Cove Trail is one mile long and involves 700 feet of elevation change.
Open only during the months of snowfree weather (generally July, August
and September), the trail allows people to walk along the shoreline for
roughly one quarter mile.
Shoreline fishing is one of the two
options you have. The second involves taking the concessioner's boat
tour, which makes a stop et Wizard lsland. Since fishing from the tour
boat is not allowed, the island is probably the best place to cast a
line. I enjoy taking the morning's first boat (usually 10 a.m.) and
staying on the island until the
Before you invest in a boat tour to
reach the island, you should know a few things. Crater Lake's rainbow
trout are a finicky species, but can grow rather large in this lake with
few natural predators. Notwithstanding their larger size, the rainbow
trout are fewer in number than the smaller and more plentiful kokonee
salmon. You should not be surprised if, on your first five casts, you
reel in a kokonee instead of a rainbow. It has happened to me on many
occasions. In fact, there are days when getting a cast fully retrieved
without a kokonee on the line can be the toughest challenge of all.

Rangers displaying catch, 1938.
Another challenge is making your way
around the shoreline of Wizard Island. The sharp, loose lava is known
for extracting bits and pieces of skin from brave visitors, primarily
from the knees and palms. If you survive the ever-biting kokonee and all
the scrapes and scratches, then you may be ready for a large rainbow
trout to come your way. How large? Well, the rumors do fly!
Like most fishing spots, the size of
the largest rainbow trout ever caught in the lake is debatable. The
park's aquatic biologist, Mark Buktenica, believes it to be the six
pound, 27 inch monster retrieved m one of his research nets during the
summer of 1991. I happened to be on the lake with Mark the day this fish
was captured, so I can confirm this claim. The biggest rainbow trout I
have caught with hook and line measured 21 inches long and weighed just
under three pounds.
What did I use to catch this beast? I
don't mind sharing my secrets because the fish were introduced and
really have no natural place in the lake's ecosystem. Consequently, as
long as they remain there, I will do my part m removing them and perhaps
you can do your fair share, too. A steel blue-colored rooster tail is
what helped me to catch that 21 inch trophy rainbow. Depending on the
time of season, other "hot" lures to use are: crawdads (the plastic
variety, as no live or organic bait is allowed), any variety of orange,
black or yellow rooster tails, flat fish (bright silver works well). If
you're a purist, flies are always a good bet (a caddie-like offering may
work especially well in mid to late summer).
Not only is the type of lure you choose
important to your success, but so is your delivery style. The key to
delivery is to be unobtrusive. Whether you are drifting a fly through
shallow coves or fishing the deep dropoffs with a spinning setup,
approach your target slowly and quietly. There is so little natural
disturbance around the island that even the slightest shadow or rockfall
will announce your presence. If the rainbow see you before your delivery
is made it is best to move somewhere else because your chance at that
spot is gone.
This fish story about Crater Lake would
not be complete without two final details. First, if you are planning to
fish all day from Wizard Island, be sure to leave yourself enough time
to get back to the dock for the last boat tour of the day. Hurrying over
the loose lava is never a good idea and it is just bad manners to make
the ranger look for you. Second, remember that whatever you decide to
take home or back to camp must make the 700 foot ascent back up the
Cleetwood Cove trail. Making friends with some of the more sturdy
looking folks on your boat ride back to the dock at Cleetwood Cove may
be a good idea if you happen to catch the "Crater Lake Monster."

Illustration by L. Howard Crawford, Nature Notes
from Crater Lake, 1935.