Nature Notes From Crater Lake
Volume 4, No. 2, August 1931
A Butterfly Pilgrimage
By Lincoln Constance, Ranger-Naturalist
Crater Lake is experiencing a migration
of butterflies resembling the flights of locusts which perturbed the
Pharaohs of Egypt in ancient times. About the South Rim one encounters
hundreds of these insects, but on Garfield and Scott Peaks one may see
thousands and tens of thousands, and multitudes are reported to be on
the wing elsewhere.
They seem to fly from all directions,
headed for everywhere at once, like a confused whirl-wind. Most of them,
however, cross the Lake from the north, perhaps in anticipation of a
pleasant winter in California, but many are enamoured by the beauty of
Crater Lake, and fly around the Rim. When automobiles arrive, the front
of their radiators are lavishly decorated with the mottled orange wings
of these butterflies.
The great majority of these insects are
the California Tortoise-shell Butterflies (Aglais californica Bdv.),
whose wings are brilliant orange within, but grayish-brown on the outer
surfaces. When they settle upon a tree trunk, or a stone, or a stray
Ranger, they close their wings, and become very inconspicuous, safe in
their protective camouflage. But the instant the wings are opened, the
momentary concealment vanishes completely. It seems to be a conception
of wide popularity that butterflies live for only a few days at best,
but these insects refute that theory, and actually hibernate over the
winter! The black, velvety caterpillars feed on various species of the
Mountain or California Lilac (Ceanothus), which locally pass
under the names of Snowbrush, Deerbrush or Buckbrush. A few whiter
butterflies: Pine Whites (Neophasia monapia F. & F.), and
Parassians (Parnassus clodius Mon.) are mingled with them,
perhaps also succumbing to the vagrant urge.

The cause and destination of migratory
movement has served tourists, and even newspapers, with much food for
conjecture and speculation. J. A. Comstock, in his "Butterflies of
California", explains the phenomenon as follows:
"It is not the response to an
instinct that prompts a southward movement in the fall for the
purpose of overwintering in favorable environment, but rather is
determined by the scarcity of food-plant, and perhaps to some extent
by the sudden subsidence of the several parasites... When conditions
are right for the production of swarms of this butterfly it is noted
that the Ceanothus bushes are entirely defoliated over great
stretches of territory in our mountains. The butterflies are
compelled to move on to other districts in order to find sufficient
food-plant on which to lay their eggs. We do not know factors that
determine the direction of this movement. Possibly it is related to
the prevailing direction of the wind since it is easier for
butterflies to fly against the wind than with it."
Tragedy lurks everywhere in the path of
the voyagers. Automobiles and careless pedestrians take a heavy toll,
but many more drop too near the water, and are drawn to its glassy,
treacherous surface. While this may be a calamity to the butterflies,
the fish appear to appreciate the addition to their staple diet, and may
frequently be seen jumping for a highly ornamented, tasty morsel.